How to Price Products for Your Online Store (Without Guessing)
Pricing too high loses buyers. Too low destroys your margin. Here's the exact framework small online sellers use to price products profitably in 2026.
Pricing is one of the most stressful decisions for new online sellers. Price too high, and buyers scroll past. Price too low and you work hard for almost nothing, or worse, you run at a loss without realising it.
The good news: pricing doesn't have to be guesswork. There's a clear process for arriving at a price that covers your costs, reflects your value, and stays competitive in your market. This guide walks through it step by step.
Quick Navigation
Common Pricing Mistakes to Avoid
Before building your pricing strategy, it helps to know what not to do. These are the mistakes that silently kill new online businesses:
Underpricing to win customers
New sellers often price low because they're not yet confident in their product's value, or because they think cheap = more sales. Sometimes it does. But low prices attract price-sensitive buyers who leave the moment you raise prices, damage your brand's perceived quality, and make it impossible to run sustainable ads or absorb delivery costs.
A buyer who pays $9 for a handmade necklace and loves it will become a repeat customer. A buyer who paid $6 for it won't. They'll expect the same price forever, or they'll assume something cheap can't be good quality.
Not accounting for all costs.
Many new sellers calculate: cost of materials + a markup. They forget to include packaging, delivery fees, platform subscription costs, the cost of unsold inventory, their own time, and payment processing fees. Then they wonder why they're busy but not profitable.
Copying a competitor's price without knowing their costs
If a competitor sells a similar item for $15, that doesn't mean $15 is right for you. Their cost structure might be completely different. They might be operating at a loss to grab market share. Or they might be paying themselves nothing. Price based on your own numbers first.
Never changing your price.
Your price is not permanent. Raw material costs change. You get better at production (lower time cost). You build a reputation (higher value). Your price should evolve with your business. Sellers who set a price in year one and never revisit it are almost always leaving money on the table.
Step 1: Know Your True Cost Per Unit
You cannot set a profitable price without knowing what each unit actually costs to produce and sell. Add up every single cost involved in getting one product to your customer.
Direct costs (per unit)
Raw materials/ingredients
Packaging (box, bag, tissue, sticker, thank-you card)
Labels and branding materials
Shipping/delivery cost to the customer
Payment processing fee (Stripe takes ~1.5%; Flutterwave varies)
Indirect costs (allocated per unit)
Your time (at a fair hourly rate) is the one sellers most often ignore
Platform subscription fee divided by expected monthly units sold
Photography equipment is amortised over the number of products
Return and refund rate (budget for: 2–5% of orders)
Example: Handmade Scented Candle
Cost Item | Amount ($) |
|---|---|
Wax, wick, and fragrance oil (per candle) | 3.50 |
Glass jar + lid | 1.50 |
Packaging (box, tissue paper, custom sticker) | 1.00 |
Shipping/Delivery cost (allocated per unit) | 4.50 |
Your labour time (30 min @ $20/hr) | 10.00 |
E-commerce platform & transaction fees | 0.50 |
True cost per unit | 21.00 |
This is your floor, the absolute minimum you can charge without losing money. Any price below $21 loses money on every sale.
Step 2: Use Cost-Plus Pricing as Your Floor
Cost-plus pricing adds a target margin on top of your true cost. For physical products, healthy gross margins are:
Handmade products: 50–70% margin (sell at 2–3.5× your material cost)
Fashion reselling: 40–60% margin
Food products: 40–60% margin
Digital products: 80–95% margin (almost no per-unit cost)
Using our candle example with a 60% gross margin target:
Formula: Selling price = True cost ÷ (1 − target margin)
$21.00 ÷ (1 − 0.60) = $21.00 ÷ 0.40 = $52.50
This gives you a floor price with a healthy margin. Now check it against the market.
Step 3: Research Competitor Pricing
Look up what similar products sell for across:
Instagram (search your product hashtag and check how sellers price)
Jumia and Konga (search your category)
Etsy (if your product has international appeal)
Other Growpins stores in your category at growpins.ai/shops
Note the range of the lowest price, the highest price, and the most common price. Ask yourself:
Where does my product sit in terms of quality relative to these?
What's different about what I offer (packaging, branding, customisation)?
Am I targeting price-sensitive buyers or quality-focused buyers?
If your cost-plus floor is within the market range, you're in good shape. If your floor is significantly above what the market charges, one of three things needs to change: your costs (source materials cheaper, improve efficiency), your positioning (justify the premium), or your product (choose something with better margins).
Step 4: Apply Value-Based Thinking
Cost-plus tells you the minimum. Value-based pricing tells you the maximum, what the buyer believes your product is worth. The gap between these two is where profit lives. Value is not just about the product. It's shaped by:
Your brand and packaging
The same candle in a plain jar sells for $10. In a branded frosted glass jar with a custom label, tissue paper, and a handwritten thank-you card, it sells for $31. The product is identical; the perceived value is not. Invest in packaging and presentation: they're the highest-return investment for most small sellers.
Your story and expertise
A skincare product made by "a seller" is a commodity. The same product made by a trained cosmetic chemist with 10 years in the beauty industry commands a premium. If you have expertise, training, or a compelling origin story, make it visible. Put it in your store's "About" section, your packaging insert, and your social media content.
Social proof
Reviews, before-and-after photos, and testimonials raise perceived value. A product with 50 positive reviews is worth more in the buyer's mind than an identical product with none. This is why getting your first reviews quickly matters so much. They unlock higher price tolerance from new buyers.
Scarcity and exclusivity
Limited batches, customisation options, or exclusive designs justify higher prices. "Available this week only" or "Only 12 made per batch" signals that what you sell is not a commodity. It's something worth securing now.
Step 5: Use Psychological Pricing Tactics
Small adjustments to how you present your price affect how buyers perceive it.
Charm pricing
$9.5 feels meaningfully cheaper than $10 to most buyers, even though the difference is 5%. Prices ending in 9, 95, or 99 consistently outperform round numbers in conversion. Use them wherever it doesn't undercut a premium positioning.
Anchor pricing
If you sell a product at one price, showing the original higher price crossed out (even for a sale) anchors the buyer's reference point higher, making the sale price feel like a better deal. Only do this when you're running a genuine promotion.
Bundle pricing
Sell individual items AND bundles (e.g., 1 candle at $9.99 or a set of 3 for $25). The bundle increases average order value and often moves items that are slower sellers individually.
Free delivery threshold
Offering free delivery on orders above a certain amount (e.g., "Free delivery on orders over $30") increases average order value. Buyers often add more items to qualify for free delivery rather than pay a delivery fee on a small order.
Tiered options
If possible, offer 2–3 versions of your product at different price points (standard, deluxe, premium). Most buyers pick the middle option. This also makes your standard option feel more accessible relative to the premium tier.
Step 6: Test and Adjust
Your first price is a hypothesis, not a commitment. The only way to know if your price is right is to watch what happens when real buyers encounter it.
Signals your price is too high
High traffic to your store but low sales (people are looking but not buying)
Many enquiries, but buyers don't proceed after hearing the price
DM conversations that go cold after you quote the price
Signals your price is too low
Sales convert easily, but you feel rushed and underpaid
You're selling a lot but not making a meaningful profit
Buyers express surprise that the price is "so low"; this signals room to go higher
You can't afford to spend on marketing because margins don't allow it
How to test a price increase
Raise your price by 10–20% and monitor conversion for 2 weeks. If sales volume drops but your total revenue stays the same or increases, the higher price is working. If conversion drops significantly, you've found the ceiling for your current market positioning.
Use Growpins' store analytics to track which products convert and which don't. Set up your store here to get access to these tools from day one.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much profit margin should I aim for?
For physical products, aim for a 40–60% gross margin as a minimum. Handmade and branded products can achieve 60–75%. Below 30% gross margin, it becomes very difficult to sustain a business once you factor in marketing costs, occasional refunds, and your own time. Digital products should target 80%+ since production cost is essentially zero after the initial creation.
Should I include the delivery cost in the listed price?
Many sellers offer "free delivery" by baking the delivery cost into the product price. This simplifies the buyer's decision; there's no unpleasant surprise at checkout. The downside is that your listed price looks higher than a competitor's (who charges separately for delivery). Test both approaches with your specific audience to see which converts better.
My competitor sells the same product cheaper. Should I match their price?
Not automatically. First, verify their quality matches yours. Second, consider whether you can compete on dimensions other than price: better packaging, faster delivery, better customer service, more trusted reviews, or a stronger brand story. A race to the lowest price destroys margin for everyone. Win on value, not on being the cheapest.
How do I price handmade products when they take a long time to make?
This is where most handmade sellers undercharge. Calculate your time at a fair hourly rate, not minimum wage, but what a skilled artisan should earn. If a product takes 3 hours at $200/hr, that's $600 in labour alone, before materials. If the resulting price feels high, either improve your efficiency, source materials more cheaply, or communicate the craftsmanship more clearly so buyers understand the value.
Can I charge more than bigger stores do?
Yes, often. Big retailers compete on volume and consistency. Small online sellers compete on uniqueness, personalisation, and the human story behind the product. Buyers willingly pay more for something handmade, custom, or from a specific person they feel connected to. Your brand story and presentation are what justify and earn that premium.
When should I offer discounts?
Use discounts strategically, not by default. Good times for discounts: launching a new product (introductory offer), moving slow inventory, seasonal promotions, rewarding loyal repeat customers, or bundling. Never offer discounts just because someone asked, it trains buyers to always ask before buying at full price.
Share this post
Have a question about this post? Contact the author